yes, finally finished all 3! And I think it’s pretty ok to use the birth name coz he starts using it himself towards the end, no? whatever!
BTW, did you know I’ve become a sneaky reader of your blog these days? Just when I think I cant get any more lazier, I do!
and I’m not coming by your blog till you hide that snow post – its burning hot in Hyderabad! and its just not fair that you get snow!
Tommyrot! Your review was great. How do you explain my burnt lunch, then?
I got your comment and thought I’d take a quick peek at your review while the pasta was on the stove, and was so caught up in it, that the thing burnt to ash with a few orange blobs that once upon a time was cheese.
The worst bit, was that I shoplifted the packet from my mum’s cupboard (we both love pasta). Stolen goods are supposed to be the sweetest, they say.
:’(
Even Brandy wouldn’t touch the stuff.
Therefore, you owe me a pasta lunch.
Unless… tell me, would a ten year old be able to enjoy the book? I’d use this scale:
Lord of the Rings – 15+
Harry Potter – 8+
Sure! You gimme the apple pie (I never never forget food owed) and I’ll send you the pasta (which, fyi, I love to bits)
And you’re right about the stolen food. It’s even tastier if the stolen contraband is food hidden for the sibling *evil look on face*
If LOTR is 15+, then Bartimaeus would also be on that level – the plot is simple enough, but one sure needs a sarcastic bend of mind to enjoy the wit and sarcasm!
Re. your response to my comment on your blog (phew!): If you’re turning 4, then I was born yesterday!
And I thought you had forgotten all about the apple pie.
You have a sibling too?
Oh Kindred Spirit, I feel for thee. Life is a constant war between The Rabid Unicorn and myself.
Especially over pastries. Oh and pasta.
“awesome ” review
(I mean it !!)
Good thing i read it right now..me planning on going to the library right now..I just hope this book’s hiding out there somewhere in the nook and corner of the library shelf
The collage is real good
Picasa work ?
ohk..at last u finished it…..the artwork on the cover looks fab!!..these books are like those of ancient lore rite?? sumwhat like the lord of the rings theme??… i ll see if i get them!!!..
Princess – Not just pastries and pasta, ALL food
I remember threatening to sue my mom for discrimination when she gave the last egg in the fridge to the brother (’coz he plays a lot and needs nourishment, indirectly calling me lazy, which though true, does hurt!) I haven’t got the apple pie yet
Nithya – Hallo, ‘awesome’? nakkals of india?
Good luck with the library (pity I dont have one here nearby)
Sharan – Not as historical as LOTR, it’s much lighter and wittier. I liked the different kind of narration a lot.
Surprisingly, I just wrote a review of the Trilogy…
I love Bartimaeus… The fellow is just the funniest spirit I have ever come across. And as you said, he has at least one footnote for every year he has been on the earth.
Are you kidding? The Bartimaeus Trilogy FAR outstrips Harry Potter. Doesn’t even come close. Don’t get me wrong, I love Harry Potter, it’s a great story, but it comes nowhere near the in-depth character development, complex moral themes, philosophical speculation, and raw emotion that exists in the Bartimaeus Trilogy.
Hmmm..I wouldn’t compare the two.. the styles are very different.. you know what, I dont know which one I like more! Maybe I like them both equally for what they are
Welcome to TP!
1 | B o o
March 22, 2007 at 9:07 am
Ah! So you finished reading. About time!
But you are nt as jobless as me and you have written an awesome review! I can never write one. Im scared that I would start hating the book after reading my own review!
It was nice to refresh my memory about the books. I loved Amulet. The other 2 were a let down after the fabulous first. I was really addicted to Bartimaeus and wanted the whole book to be about him. What an enchanting creature, huh? Lucky Ptolemy and Nathaniel! (Oops! Is it ok to take his birth name?)